Judges vs. Lawyers: An Imaginary Showdown
Liu Chang
Southern Weekly, September 4, 2012
![]() |
Defendants in the Bai Yugang trial make their final statements. Source: Nanyang Intermediate People’s Court |
Investigation
![]() |
Liu Deshan kept a journal on scraps of paper during his detention. Source: Liu Chang, Southern Weekly |
Trial
Emphasizing Severity
Lawyers Can Bring Public Discontent into the Realm of Rationality
Related links:
Steely Resolve Needed to Push Forward Reforms
Related links:
Steely Resolve Needed to Push Forward Reforms
Related links:
![]() |
Renowned legal scholar and Peking University Professor He Weifang discussing legal reforms. Photo credit: China Business View |
Judges Should Only Express Themselves to Society Through Judgments
…
…
Related Links
While there’s nothing surprising about the publication of a senior leader’s views in a central government newspaper, publishing those views for the first time more than 18 months after being first articulated is rather unusual. This curious situation is alluded to in an editorial (translated below) published in the December 8 edition of Southern Daily (南方日报), the official newspaper of the Guangdong Province Branch of the Chinese Communist Party and part of a family of publications known for in-depth reporting and outspoken views.
The editorial, which was widely republished on official media websites throughout China, focuses on Wen’s explication of one of the mottoes of CUPL, “Governing by law” (法治天下), which he equates with the idea of “supremacy of the law” (法比天大)—literally, “the law is greater than heaven.” Bluntly acknowledging that abuses of power by officials have hindered the development of faith in China’s legal system, the editorial urges readers to reflect on this failure and stresses the importance of enforcement, transparency, and participation as keys to building a society under rule of law.
Legal Daily recently featured the full transcript of a talk that Premier Wen Jiabao gave on May 4, 2008, to students at China University of Political Science and Law. Premier Wen said, “The importance of the law can simply not be overemphasized,” “ ‘Governing by law’ means ‘the law is supreme’” and “The difficulty of ruling lies not in making laws, but in making others follow the law. It is better to have no laws than laws that are not followed.”
It is unclear why, after a year and a half, Legal Daily was so late to publish the transcript of Premier Wen’s talk. Perhaps it is simply to re-emphasize the importance of the law. [As for] the law being “greater than heaven,” first one must be clear about what is meant by “heaven.” To some people, especially officials, “heaven” seems to be authority, either those people who allow them to have power or the myriad advantages that power brings. Within the jurisdictions of some people [whose ethos is] “I am number one” and “I am the law,” neither the law nor heaven is of any use; only they themselves are effective.
The more common this phenomenon, the more inevitably it causes people to develop many doubts about rule of law. If ordinary people have problems, the first thing they think of is not taking the matter to court, but rather going to Beijing to petition. The dramatic increase in the number of petitioners in recent years is not just a result of economic development bringing about more social conflict; we also need to look at the problem of insufficient development of rule of law. Over the years, more and more laws have been established, but what truly defines a society under rule of law is not how many laws there are but, rather, whether people act in accordance with legal norms, whether those with power respect the law, and whether the law rules supreme over authority. Unfortunately, the administration of justice continues to encounter pressure from all sorts of public power, as evidenced by the fact that lawsuits against the government rarely succeed, [because] judges sometimes do not decide cases on the basis of the law, but on the basis of official instructions. After years of this, why should ordinary people have faith in the law? Why shouldn’t officials see the legal system as their plaything? We often say that the administration of justice is the baseline for fairness, but then why are there judgments that pervert the law and interference in the administration of justice? Doesn’t this show that society still suffers from the stubborn disease of authority being above the law?
Such stubborn diseases must be eliminated, even if it means paying a high price. For if authority being above the law is allowed to spread further, [the idea of] “society under rule of law” will be reduced to nothing but a tattered fig leaf, and the resulting weakening of social restraint will be a cost far greater than that which accompanies curing a stubborn disease. In fact, “supremacy of the law” is only the essence of a society under rule of law, something that could not be more a matter of common sense. That it sounds so enlightening when uttered by the premier just shows how lacking we are in common sense. We should reflect on why a truly common faith in the law has not yet been established. Why is the administration of justice faced with all sorts of constraints? Why is the legal system itself designed in ways that do not fully adhere to legal common sense? In analyzing this question, we cannot simply look at external factors but must examine internal ones as well. More effective construction of rule of law, opening up the legislative process and oversight of the law, and promoting a democratic judicial system—all of these would be welcome measures.
The “supremacy of the law” of which Premier Wen spoke is one founded on the premise of a rule of law. Some intentionally twist the phrase to mean that the law is so supreme that it does not have to consider or care about anything else. This is clearly an unreliable interpretation. Premier Wen’s “supremacy of the law” is one in which laws must be observed, one in which there is respect for the law—and especially respect for good laws. This does not mean that all laws are legitimate and constitutional: the former system of “custody and repatriation” is a classic example of a bad law. In addition, recent years have witnessed the phenomenon of “departmental legislative guidance” in the legislative process, something that needs to be guarded against. Government ministries, commissions, and departments that are prevented from participating in the drafting of legislation concerning them have not only insisted on participating but have even played a leading role in guiding the legislative process, with the result that too many departmental interests are manifested in the laws themselves, to the detriment of the public interest. These kinds of laws are the result of a closed-door legislative process, one that ultimately leads to social injustice and hinders the establishment of judicial authority.
“Supremacy of the law” tells us that we must establish faith in the administration of justice in all sectors of society. In order to establish such faith and give the justice system the authority to oversee all matters, we must further reform the external and internal environment for the legal system, curb inappropriate interference in the administration of justice, and promote a democratic judicial process.
Even though the libel charge against Wang was dropped and some efforts were made to “redress” the situation, the furor that erupted over his case and its aftermath shows Chinese citizens’ concern over the excessive power wielded by local governments, which are often believed to be out to protect themselves instead of lawfully defending the public interest. The case also exposes the potential hazards of open expression over the Internet for the increasing numbers of Chinese who view online communication as an effective method for sharing opinions about the world around them—even on subjects as sensitive as alleged wrongdoing by government officials.
Translated by Dui Hua, the two commentaries below by Chinese scholars—about pervasive problems of rule of law and the limits of free expression exposed by Wang Shuai’s case and other libel cases—have recently appeared in the official Chinese press. The first article, ‘“Lingbao post case”: Who should apologize more?,” was written by Dr. Yu Jianrong, a prominent scholar with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. The piece (original Chinese text) critiques the issue of legal responsibility in such cases and emphasizes the importance of being persistent in taking on local government corruption.
The second translation is of an article (original Chinese text) just published on April 30, “The Winner in the ‘Wang Shuai Post Case’ is ‘Power,’ not ‘the Law,’” by Sheng Dalin, a well-known lawyer, media critic, and writer. In his commentary, Sheng decries that even the “resolution” of the case was orchestrated by the main local power brokers—the Lingbao Party Committee and city government—and, as such, an appropriate procedure that recognizes tenets of law was not followed.
Yesterday, Qin Yuhai, Henan vice governor and chief of the provincial public security department, visited with the People’s Daily website to discuss the incident of the “cross-provincial arrest in Lingbao, Henan, of Wang Shuai, the online poster.” He indicated that local public security organs had made mistakes in enforcing the law, that Wang Shuai’s case did not conform to conditions of the crime of defamation, and that [Wang] had already received state compensation. Qin Yuhai also apologized for the incident and said the Henan Province Public Security Department had sent a team to Lingbao to conduct an investigation (April 16 People’s Daily website). On April 10, when Wang Shuai and I agreed to be interviewed together by the People’s Daily website, I was still concerned about whether he would be arrested and taken into custody again. Now, with Qin Yuhai having taken this position, we can rest assured, but the matter cannot end here.
Although Qin Yuhai also serves as vice governor of Henan Province, his statement mainly is made from the perspective of the public security system, and criticism is being directed at the problem of arbitrary law enforcement by public security departments. But there has yet been no clear answer regarding whether the Lingbao public security departments got involved in the case because of pressure or direct instructions from the local government.
A public security organ should carry out the sacred duties as major enforcers of the nation’s laws and the protectors of society, work in accordance with the law, and place the interests of the masses first. But it also is a government department, [and] its personnel matters, finances, and operations must be subject to the jurisdiction of government at the same level. So it is inevitable at times that a number of local political interests creep in. Police power is often abused not by local police themselves, but by those who use their authority to employ police power. In dealing with thorny issues such as land requisition, some local governments force police to overstep their authority.
The “Pengshui poem case” in Chongqing, the “Jishan document case” in Shanxi, the “Zhidan SMS case” in Shaanxi, and the “Gaotang Internet case” in Shandong—a lot of behavior clearly falling within the scope of freedom of speech has been pinned with the label of “defamation,” and public power has been employed abusively in carrying out interrogation, arrest, and prosecution, all for “causing a [negative] impact on local economic development” or “damaging the local image.” It’s clearly unimaginable that all of this can take place without specific power-holders in the background deliberately “governing illegally and abusing office,” “suppressing criticism and controlling public opinion,” or “perverting the law to suit one’s own selfish needs.” In Wang Shuai’s case, the public has reason to question the role the Lingbao City government played and whether or not there was abuse of police power, and [the public] even hopes to see someone held responsible for the incident. Besides the apology by Qin Yuhai, an even more standard way of doing things for a society with rule of law would be for the Lingbao City government or a higher-level government to officially publicize the details of Wang Shuai’s case, including the entire process of its occurrence up to the recognition that the case was faulty, the specific staff who must take responsibility, and the handling of decisions by relevant departments and staff. [These actions] will make the conduct of those in power more open and transparent.
The Wang Shuai “defamation case” simply should never have happened, and withdrawing the faulty case now only solves a derivative problem. The incident emerged as a response to unlawful land use by the Lingbao City government, and this is where [our] attention should return. Since Wang Shuai did not commit libel, the Lingbao City government should provide a clear response to Wang Shuai and the public regarding the issue of illegal land requisition that he raised. If the public has misunderstandings because of Wang Shuai’s post and if the Lingbao City government thinks the image of the local government has been tarnished, then the government is obliged to clarify the actual situation, respond to the suspicions of netizens, and dispel their doubts. Without effective communication, the masses who don’t know the truth will never understand [the situation]. If the issues in Wang Shuai’s case are valid (on April 16, the China Youth Daily reported the requisition of over 27 square kilometers [of land]), the Lingbao City government should not conceal this, but instead acknowledge the problem, take responsibility, and seek an effective solution. Whether through restoration of farmland, remedial measures, or pursuit of greater land compensation, [the government] needs to provide a clear response to those affected and to members of society who care about this issue.
After attracting so much attention, if this matter simply went away without being resolved, it would actually do great damage to the image of the local government. It would seem to send the message that whatever local governments want to do—legal or not and regardless of whether a citizen who voices criticism is sent to prison or if farmers are pushed off their land at a low price [in compensation]—can be achieved through a variety of methods. Even if [such actions] bring about serious consequences, the government also can pass the buck for various reasons, with its own illegal acts falling outside the bounds of the law.
According to an April 29 report in The Beijing News, the Sanmenxia Party Committee and city government held a meeting to “seriously punish” the illegal occupation of land in Lingbao City that had been exposed in the “Wang Shuai post case.” The Lingbao City Party Committee and city government were ordered to carry out a thorough investigation for the Sanmenxia Party Committee and city governmnent, and Lingbao City Party Secretary Lü Junping and Mayor Qiao Changqing were ordered to carry out a thorough investigation for the Sanmenxia Party Committee and city government. It was decided to punish those officials who were found to be responsible.
So now, the “Wang Shuai post case” that has made such a stir throughout the nation can be said to have come to a close. No doubt many citizens who offered encouragement and support to Wang Shuai will be very happy with this result, but I can’t help but feel that the conclusion is less than perfect.
The final outcome of the “Wang Shuai post case” is certainly just as we had hoped. But did we only want to see the outcome? No—outcomes are important, but the process is important, too. We wanted to see substantive justice done, but we also wanted to see procedural justice as well. However, looking back at the entire course of the “Wang Shuai post case,” we must admit that the course of action taken was not the ideal choice.
Actually, there are many paths that could have been taken to achieve a just outcome. For example, the public security bureau could have strictly handled the case in accordance with the law and refused to file the case for investigation or withdrawn the case in accordance with the law after public opinion pointed out that the charge of “defamation” was completely untenable. But it did neither of these. After the storm of public opinion, not only did Lingbao City have no intention of rectifying the case, it actually fought back hard against public opinion. Only intervention by the Henan Province Public Security Department and Vice Governor and Public Security Department Chief Qin Yuhai’s public admission that “defamation is untenable” was there a sudden shift in their course.
It’s a clear fact that, from start to finish, the main actor in handling this case, the Lingbao City Public Security Bureau, was secondary to the Lingbao City Party Committee and city government, which was in the driver’s seat. It was the party committee and government that made public statements, and it was always the publicity department of the city party committee, speaking on behalf of the city party committee and government, that gave media interviews. Obviously, the “filing” in this case was a result of the intervention of power and its “withdrawal” was a result of the intervention of power as well. From the beginning, what the city public security bureau was enforcing was not the “law,” but rather “orders” from superiors. Even though the oversight of public opinion played an important role, what ultimately brought about a reversal in these events was power. In other words, the winner in the “Wang Shuai post case” was “power,” not “the law.”
This is not an isolated situation. From the “Pengshui poem case” to the “Jishan document case,” in recent years there have been several “defamation” cases that were nothing more than the result of “power overshadowing the law.” In the Wu Baoquan case in Hohhot [sic, should be Ordos], Inner Mongolia, there have even been a few judges and prosecutors handling the case who have openly expressed their frustration at being unable to handle the case in accordance with the law.
“Supremacy of the law” is the first tenet of the rule of law. “Power overshadows the law” is a vestige of the rule of man. Even though the “Wang Shuai post case” was recently overturned and the responsible people concerned have received “serious punishments,” not a single hair has been harmed on the “chief culprit” in this case and others like it—namely, the idea that “power overshadows the law.” Unless we eradicate this “chief culprit,” individual rights such as freedom of speech can never be protected and cases involving the punishment of free speech will never cease.