Tag: torture

  • Zhejiang Daily Compiles Morose Compendium of “Unnatural Deaths” in Detention

    Voices in the Chinese public, from common netizens to prominent legal experts, are increasingly strengthening calls for greater accountability in the country’s criminal justice system, like with the recent case of Zhao Zuohai. Criticisms of how China’s criminal justice and law enforcement organs function—and official government responses—have sparked debate about whether popular opinion is driving the development of rule of law in China or simply contributing to digital-age mob justice.  

    The cases that may have attracted the most public ire are those in which a miscarriage of justice is compounded by an inept administrative cover-up. In an early 2009 case of “death by ‘blind man’s bluff,’” for example, citizens ridiculed local officials who claimed that a detainee in Yunnan Province died after bumping his head while playing a game with his cellmates. The naming convention that has emerged around these cases—such as, among several others, “death by nightmare,” “death by picking at acne,” and “death by drinking water”—is a glib poke at the official line that time and again accompanies these tragedies, a line that clumsily obfuscates the most commonly suspected cause of the deaths, which is abuse at the hands of detention center personnel.

    On June 24, the Zhejiang Daily published a spread (translated below) that compiled accounts from other sources of “unnatural deaths” in Chinese detention centers. Certainly not exhaustive, this list is accompanied by a graphic (below, click to enlarge) that depicts the victims as anonymous figures labeled with their official cause of death. It is then followed by a piece of reportage that focuses on the Detention Center Management Bureau of the Ministry of Public Security and efforts to curb abuses in detention. 

    From “Blind Man’s Bluff” to “Face Washing”

    Urgently Awaiting the End of Unnatural Deaths in Detention Centers 

    Zhejiang Daily, June 24, 2010


    Key points: 
         Detention centers are said to be a touchstone for testing the rule-of-law progress of a nation or region. 
         A series of unnatural deaths in recent years have thrust these facilities, once shrouded in mystery, before the public view and placed them at the center of a storm. 

    Countless varieties of unnatural death
         Many netizens have commented extensively on the series of unnatural deaths in detention centers over recent years and given each one an accordingly bizarre name.
    • Death by “blind man’s bluff”: In February 2009, when Li Qiaoming died in the detention center of the Puning County (Yunnan) Public Security Bureau, police said that he had suffered serious injuries from bumping into a wall while playing “blind man’s bluff” with fellow inmates. Subsequent investigation determined that he had been beaten to death by prison bullies.
    • Death by showering: In March 2009, a 57-year-old Hainan man died in the Danzhou (Hainan) Number One Detention Center. Police said that the incident arose when a suspect told him to undress and shower; he refused and was beaten to death.
    • Death by falling out of bed: In March 2009, 20-year-old Fujian youth Wen Longhui died suddenly in the Fuzhou (Fujian) Number Two Detention Center. The detention center said he had fallen out of bed as a result of sudden death or illness.
    • Death by nightmare: In March 2009, the Jiujiang (Jiangxi) Detention Center said that a Hunan man named Li Wenyan died suddenly in the middle of the night after having a nightmare.
    • Death from sleeping in an improper position: In April 2009, a Fuzhou student surnamed Chen died suddenly in the Fuqing City (Fujian) Public Order Lockup. Police said his sleep position was improper and that he was unresponsive to efforts to awaken him and died after efforts to revive him were unsuccessful.
    • Death by going crazy: In June 2009, when a youth named Lin Lifeng died in the Wuchuan City (Guangdong) Number Two Detention Center, police said he had “died after going crazy.” The procuratorate ultimately ruled the death as “sudden cardiac arrest.”
    • Death by picking at acne: In November 2009, Yu Weiping from Gaocun Town, Wendeng City, Shandong, died while being held in a detention center. Upon inspecting the body, his family found small holes on his chest, which the detention center claimed were caused by his picking at acne. A subsequent autopsy revealed that the death was caused by cardiac rupture following repeated stabbing with a sharp, needle-like object.
    • Death from agitation: In December 2009, a Shaanxi woman named Wang Huixia was taken away by police and died an unnatural death after 20 hours of questioning. Police said her death was triggered by agitation and anxiety.
    • Death by drinking water: In February 2010, a young Henan man died in a detention center in Lushan County. Police said that he suddenly took ill and died from drinking boiled water during an interrogation.
    • Death by tripping: In February 2010, criminal suspect Chen Xujin died in the detention center in Xiushui County, Jiujiang, Jiangxi. Police said that he tripped in the toilet and died suddenly. A doctor claimed he was forced to make a false [report].
    • Death by going to the toilet: In March 2010, a major criminal offender died under mysterious circumstances in Tuoketuo County, Hohhot, Inner Mongolia. Police explained that [the death] happened when he fell going to the toilet in the middle of the night.
    • Death by insufficient evidence: In 2010, after two trials no verdict was returned in the case of Pu Zemin from Mianyang, Sichuan, because of insufficient evidence. Pu Zemin ultimately died under mysterious circumstances in the detention center.
    • Death by face-washing: In April 2010, a man died a bizarre death in the administrative lockup of Gong’an County, Jingzhou, Hubei. Police said that the man had drowned in the face-washing basin.
    When will bizarre deaths end? 

         ”I listen and think it’s ridiculous, because it’s simply impossible,” said a former director general of the Detention Center Management Bureau of the Ministry of Public Security (MPS) about the series of unnatural deaths such as “death by nightmare,” “death by drinking water,” “death by going to the toilet,” “death by face-washing.” “Most are [the result of] beatings.” First is coerced confessions during the investigation stage. Police hit someone and initially it doesn’t seem like a big problem, but then [the suspect] is locked up and doesn’t [receive] immediate treatment and [the injury] spreads and leads to death. Second is when the detention center tries to solve a case: the eagerness for quick results and unrealistic expectations [leads to] disregard for roughing someone up. Third is handing over management authority to inmate enforcers, who wield a great deal of power. If you give this authority to someone ruthless like a murderer, it’s very possible he’ll beat someone to death.
         In April of this year, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate held a tele-linked meeting at which it was revealed that this year 15 cases of unnatural detainee deaths in 12 provinces had been reported to the Procuratorial Department for Prisons and Detention Centers. Three were reported as suicides, seven had been beaten to death, two died as a result of accidents, and three deaths were still under investigation. An official from the department said that unnatural deaths in detention centers were the result of both lax management by the public security organs and weak oversight by procuratorates.
         ”The complexity of the problems in detention centers are owing to many years of long-standing abuses,” says Chen Weidong, professor at the Renmin University School of Law. “Looking back at the past 60 years of the development of detention centers [in China], one can see that there have essentially been no changes in detention center management or mechanisms to protect rights.” He said that this whole time, detention centers overemphasized the guarding and reform of detainees, as well as even uncovering crime and assisting in the punishment of crime. However, the function of protecting human rights has never been demonstrated, making it difficult to adapt to the demands of modern rule of law. 

    Reform is only possible solution 

         MPS Detention Center Management Bureau Director Zhao Chunguang says: “Public security detention work has to open up more to the public in order to eliminate the feeling of mystery. We should let the public know and see that it’s not the least bit hidden from view.” If the public does not trust public security detention work, it is to some extent the fault of public security detention being closed, secret, and insufficiently transparent.
         Since 2009, the MPS Detention Center Management Bureau has opened 150 detention centers to the public in two batches. Public security detention facilities all over have been opening up to the public in all sorts of ways, including inviting the media to conduct interviews; arranging inspections by Party and government leaders, delegates to the people’s congresses and political consultative conferences, and specially invited monitors; and hosting detainees’ family members and lawyers and holding roundtable meetings.
         The death of Sun Zhigang brought about reform of the custody and repatriation system. Now, people all over are watching to see whether the string of unnatural deaths occurring throughout the country will bring about new changes for detention centers.
         In the view of some scholars, the real way to cure [the problems facing] detention centers is to separate [criminal] investigation from [suspect] custody, with public security departments exercising the authority to investigate and authority over detention being transferred to judicial administration departments.
         Professor Gu Yongzhong of China University of Politics and Law points out that even if public security organs managed [detention facilities] better, suspicions would always remain. Tsinghua University Law School Professor Zhang Jianwei believes that, compared to the current system that relies on internal monitoring, [a system of] external [monitoring] would be more significant and valuable.
         In April of this year, Specially Appointed MPS Monitor, National People’s Congress Deputy, and Furun Holdings Group Board Chairman Zhao Linzhong participated in an detention center inspection program organized by the MPS. He believes that the fundamental cure must involve revision of detention center regulations as soon as possible. “Those regulations haven’t been changed in 20 years, and some of the provisions aren’t in accord with developments or the progress of the nation’s legal institutions.”
         Presently, the nation’s public security organs are undergoing a focused effort to repair the damage and bring an end once and for all to incidents involving the unnatural deaths of criminal suspects during the law enforcement process. [New] regulations clearly state that, in cases in which the unnatural death of suspects is due to an official’s failure to pay attention or carry out [the necessary] work, those officials with direct or shared responsibility will without exception be suspended from duty and, pending thorough investigation of the facts, handled according to disciplinary [rules] and the law.
  • Zhejiang Daily Compiles Morose Compendium of “Unnatural Deaths” in Detention

    Voices in the Chinese public, from common netizens to prominent legal experts, are increasingly strengthening calls for greater accountability in the country’s criminal justice system, like with the recent case of Zhao Zuohai. Criticisms of how China’s criminal justice and law enforcement organs function—and official government responses—have sparked debate about whether popular opinion is driving the development of rule of law in China or simply contributing to digital-age mob justice.  
     
    The cases that may have attracted the most public ire are those in which a miscarriage of justice is compounded by an inept administrative cover-up. In an early 2009 case of “death by ‘blind man’s bluff,’” for example, citizens ridiculed local officials who claimed that a detainee in Yunnan Province died after bumping his head while playing a game with his cellmates. The naming convention that has emerged around these cases—such as, among several others, “death by nightmare,” “death by picking at acne,” and “death by drinking water”—is a glib poke at the official line that time and again accompanies these tragedies, a line that clumsily obfuscates the most commonly suspected cause of the deaths, which is abuse at the hands of detention center personnel.
    On June 24, the Zhejiang Daily published a spread (translated below) that compiled accounts from other sources of “unnatural deaths” in Chinese detention centers. Certainly not exhaustive, this list is accompanied by a graphic (below, click to enlarge) that depicts the victims as anonymous figures labeled with their official cause of death. It is then followed by a piece of reportage that focuses on the Detention Center Management Bureau of the Ministry of Public Security and efforts to curb abuses in detention. 

    From “Blind Man’s Bluff” to “Face Washing”

    Urgently Awaiting the End of Unnatural Deaths in Detention Centers 

    Zhejiang Daily, June 24, 2010

     
    Key points: 
         Detention centers are said to be a touchstone for testing the rule-of-law progress of a nation or region. 
         A series of unnatural deaths in recent years have thrust these facilities, once shrouded in mystery, before the public view and placed them at the center of a storm. 
     
    Countless varieties of unnatural death
         Many netizens have commented extensively on the series of unnatural deaths in detention centers over recent years and given each one an accordingly bizarre name.
    • Death by “blind man’s bluff”: In February 2009, when Li Qiaoming died in the detention center of the Puning County (Yunnan) Public Security Bureau, police said that he had suffered serious injuries from bumping into a wall while playing “blind man’s bluff” with fellow inmates. Subsequent investigation determined that he had been beaten to death by prison bullies.
    • Death by showering: In March 2009, a 57-year-old Hainan man died in the Danzhou (Hainan) Number One Detention Center. Police said that the incident arose when a suspect told him to undress and shower; he refused and was beaten to death.
    • Death by falling out of bed: In March 2009, 20-year-old Fujian youth Wen Longhui died suddenly in the Fuzhou (Fujian) Number Two Detention Center. The detention center said he had fallen out of bed as a result of sudden death or illness.
    • Death by nightmare: In March 2009, the Jiujiang (Jiangxi) Detention Center said that a Hunan man named Li Wenyan died suddenly in the middle of the night after having a nightmare.
    • Death from sleeping in an improper position: In April 2009, a Fuzhou student surnamed Chen died suddenly in the Fuqing City (Fujian) Public Order Lockup. Police said his sleep position was improper and that he was unresponsive to efforts to awaken him and died after efforts to revive him were unsuccessful.
    • Death by going crazy: In June 2009, when a youth named Lin Lifeng died in the Wuchuan City (Guangdong) Number Two Detention Center, police said he had “died after going crazy.” The procuratorate ultimately ruled the death as “sudden cardiac arrest.”
    • Death by picking at acne: In November 2009, Yu Weiping from Gaocun Town, Wendeng City, Shandong, died while being held in a detention center. Upon inspecting the body, his family found small holes on his chest, which the detention center claimed were caused by his picking at acne. A subsequent autopsy revealed that the death was caused by cardiac rupture following repeated stabbing with a sharp, needle-like object.
    • Death from agitation: In December 2009, a Shaanxi woman named Wang Huixia was taken away by police and died an unnatural death after 20 hours of questioning. Police said her death was triggered by agitation and anxiety.
    • Death by drinking water: In February 2010, a young Henan man died in a detention center in Lushan County. Police said that he suddenly took ill and died from drinking boiled water during an interrogation.
    • Death by tripping: In February 2010, criminal suspect Chen Xujin died in the detention center in Xiushui County, Jiujiang, Jiangxi. Police said that he tripped in the toilet and died suddenly. A doctor claimed he was forced to make a false [report].
    • Death by going to the toilet: In March 2010, a major criminal offender died under mysterious circumstances in Tuoketuo County, Hohhot, Inner Mongolia. Police explained that [the death] happened when he fell going to the toilet in the middle of the night.
    • Death by insufficient evidence: In 2010, after two trials no verdict was returned in the case of Pu Zemin from Mianyang, Sichuan, because of insufficient evidence. Pu Zemin ultimately died under mysterious circumstances in the detention center.
    • Death by face-washing: In April 2010, a man died a bizarre death in the administrative lockup of Gong’an County, Jingzhou, Hubei. Police said that the man had drowned in the face-washing basin.
    When will bizarre deaths end? 
     
         ”I listen and think it’s ridiculous, because it’s simply impossible,” said a former director general of the Detention Center Management Bureau of the Ministry of Public Security (MPS) about the series of unnatural deaths such as “death by nightmare,” “death by drinking water,” “death by going to the toilet,” “death by face-washing.” “Most are [the result of] beatings.” First is coerced confessions during the investigation stage. Police hit someone and initially it doesn’t seem like a big problem, but then [the suspect] is locked up and doesn’t [receive] immediate treatment and [the injury] spreads and leads to death. Second is when the detention center tries to solve a case: the eagerness for quick results and unrealistic expectations [leads to] disregard for roughing someone up. Third is handing over management authority to inmate enforcers, who wield a great deal of power. If you give this authority to someone ruthless like a murderer, it’s very possible he’ll beat someone to death.
         In April of this year, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate held a tele-linked meeting at which it was revealed that this year 15 cases of unnatural detainee deaths in 12 provinces had been reported to the Procuratorial Department for Prisons and Detention Centers. Three were reported as suicides, seven had been beaten to death, two died as a result of accidents, and three deaths were still under investigation. An official from the department said that unnatural deaths in detention centers were the result of both lax management by the public security organs and weak oversight by procuratorates.
         ”The complexity of the problems in detention centers are owing to many years of long-standing abuses,” says Chen Weidong, professor at the Renmin University School of Law. “Looking back at the past 60 years of the development of detention centers [in China], one can see that there have essentially been no changes in detention center management or mechanisms to protect rights.” He said that this whole time, detention centers overemphasized the guarding and reform of detainees, as well as even uncovering crime and assisting in the punishment of crime. However, the function of protecting human rights has never been demonstrated, making it difficult to adapt to the demands of modern rule of law. 
     
    Reform is only possible solution 
     
         MPS Detention Center Management Bureau Director Zhao Chunguang says: “Public security detention work has to open up more to the public in order to eliminate the feeling of mystery. We should let the public know and see that it’s not the least bit hidden from view.” If the public does not trust public security detention work, it is to some extent the fault of public security detention being closed, secret, and insufficiently transparent.
         Since 2009, the MPS Detention Center Management Bureau has opened 150 detention centers to the public in two batches. Public security detention facilities all over have been opening up to the public in all sorts of ways, including inviting the media to conduct interviews; arranging inspections by Party and government leaders, delegates to the people’s congresses and political consultative conferences, and specially invited monitors; and hosting detainees’ family members and lawyers and holding roundtable meetings.
         The death of Sun Zhigang brought about reform of the custody and repatriation system. Now, people all over are watching to see whether the string of unnatural deaths occurring throughout the country will bring about new changes for detention centers.
         In the view of some scholars, the real way to cure [the problems facing] detention centers is to separate [criminal] investigation from [suspect] custody, with public security departments exercising the authority to investigate and authority over detention being transferred to judicial administration departments.
         Professor Gu Yongzhong of China University of Politics and Law points out that even if public security organs managed [detention facilities] better, suspicions would always remain. Tsinghua University Law School Professor Zhang Jianwei believes that, compared to the current system that relies on internal monitoring, [a system of] external [monitoring] would be more significant and valuable.
         In April of this year, Specially Appointed MPS Monitor, National People’s Congress Deputy, and Furun Holdings Group Board Chairman Zhao Linzhong participated in an detention center inspection program organized by the MPS. He believes that the fundamental cure must involve revision of detention center regulations as soon as possible. “Those regulations haven’t been changed in 20 years, and some of the provisions aren’t in accord with developments or the progress of the nation’s legal institutions.”
         Presently, the nation’s public security organs are undergoing a focused effort to repair the damage and bring an end once and for all to incidents involving the unnatural deaths of criminal suspects during the law enforcement process. [New] regulations clearly state that, in cases in which the unnatural death of suspects is due to an official’s failure to pay attention or carry out [the necessary] work, those officials with direct or shared responsibility will without exception be suspended from duty and, pending thorough investigation of the facts, handled according to disciplinary [rules] and the law.
  • Chinese Lawyer Interviewed on New Measures to Prevent Torture: “Key to Stopping Torture Is Presence of Counsel, Right to Silence”

    Over the past ten days, the Chinese media have been reporting on the recent adoption of two new sets of rules by China’s five main law enforcement institutions—the Supreme People’s Court, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security, the Ministry of State Security, and the Ministry of Justice. The “Regulations on Several Questions Concerning the Investigation and Judgment of Evidence in Handling Capital Cases” and “Regulations on Several Questions Concerning the Exclusion of Illegal Evidence in Handling Criminal Cases” (referred to below as “the regulations”) set out new procedural standards aimed at preventing criminal cases from being decided on the basis of illegally obtained evidence, especially evidence obtained through physical torture.
    As one might imagine, the coverage has been overwhelmingly positive, with several respected legal scholars endorsing the adoption of the regulations as major progress in China’s legal reform. The announcement of the rules could not be more timely considering the scandalous discovery last month that a man named Zhao Zuohai had served 11 years of a death sentence commuted to life imprisonment for a murder he did not commit, all because of a confession that had been extracted through police torture. But true assessment of the impact the new rules will likely have on preventing future cases of injustice must await their publication—at the time of this writing, the actual texts had not yet been released—and, more importantly, consideration of how thoroughly and enthusiastically they will be enforced.
    While acknowledging the importance of the new regulations as a first step, some Chinese lawyers in particular have pointed out that the problem of torture and use of illegal evidence is a systemic problem in China’s criminal justice system and that the new regulations might not be strong enough medicine to cure the disease. In a lengthy interview (translation below) with the Beijing News published on June 5, well-known criminal defense lawyer Xu Lanting argues that giving suspects the right to remain silent and, even more importantly, the right to have a lawyer present during questioning, would have a much greater impact on curbing the problem of coerced confessions.
    [Translator’s note: Chinese texts rarely refer to “torture” (kuxing) in discussions of the domestic context. China’s Criminal Law prohibits the use of corporal punishment or “disguised” corporal punishment to obtain a confession from a suspect or a witness statement, and this is the primary basis upon which China claims to prohibit torture. To reflect this practice, the text below routinely translates xingxun bigong literally as “coercion of confession,” rather than extrapolating with the word “torture.”]
    *
    1. Having interrogators appear in court is of great significance
    Beijing News (BN): Media reports on the regulations have universally focused on the sections concerning coerced confessions. How do you rate this content?
    Xu Lanting: Each country primarily uses “rules on the exclusion of evidence” to stop coerced confessions, for example by ruling that evidence obtained through coerced confessions is illegal and cannot be used. This forces the investigating organ to stop relying on coerced confessions to obtain evidence.
         The enactment and thorough enforcement of these new regulations are of major significance in [the effort to] stop the coercion of confessions and other illegal methods of obtaining evidence, as well as in the protection of human rights.
         First of all, they overcome past limitations that excluded only illegal statements and clarify that illegally obtained physical evidence and documentary evidence will also be excluded. “When physical evidence or documentary evidence is clearly obtained in violation of the law and could possibly have an impact on the fairness of the adjudication, [the court] should order redress or make a reasonable explanation; otherwise, the physical evidence or documentary evidence in question may not be used to determine a case.”
    BN: I understand that in some countries any evidence obtained through coerced statements is categorically excluded. Are there loopholes in our regulations?
    Xu: In the United States, this kind of evidence is called “fruit of the poisonous tree” and is categorically excluded. There’s debate about this among Chinese academics. Some advocate that consideration be made of specific circumstances on a case-by-case basis, [and so] if the violations of law involved in obtaining some physical evidence is not too serious or it can be used after making redress, it shouldn’t be excluded.
         My own view is that any physical evidence obtained in ways that violate the law—especially through leads provided in coerced confessions—should also be excluded. Otherwise, there will be no way to eliminate coerced confessions. [The investigator] will think, “I’ll beat you first to get a confession. I might not be able to use that confession, but I can then rely on that confession to find other evidence.”
    BN: What breakthroughs do the regulations have in the area of procedures for excluding illegal evidence?
    Xu: The regulations establish five procedural stages: initiation of the proceedings, preliminary court investigation, the prosecution’s presentation of proof, examination of the evidence by both sides, and the court’s decision. In the past, provisions in this area only took the form of principles or slogans. Now there is a big improvement because there is a clear procedure that is more practicable.
         It’s worth pointing out that, unlike in the past, investigators will give testimony in court. Also, if the prosecution’s evidence is not credible or sufficient enough to rule out that a defendant’s pre-trial statements were obtained illegally, the court may rule those statements to be illegal and exclude them. On a certain level, this can be seen as “inverting the burden of proof” and forcing the investigating organ to preserve the interrogation [process] through audio and video recording.
    BN: But this so-called [requirement that] investigators give testimony in court is still passive, being initiated only after defendants or their defense attorneys make allegations of coerced confessions. Why can’t China do like some other countries and make court appearances by investigators routine?
    Xu: It’s true that in some countries it’s routine for investigators to testify in court. In countries that follow the Anglo-American system of law, investigators are treated as witnesses and all witnesses must appear in court or else their testimony is treated as hearsay and cannot be used. I’ve also observed that some European countries’ trial systems make their investigators appear in court, even if only to state how they originally took the suspect into custody.
         Our regulations can only be considered a “limited principle on court appearance,” but this is realistic and reasonable. First, it’s probably impossible at present to make investigators in each case appear in court, and it’s not necessary. If there’s no argument over the records and statements, then there’s no need [for investigators] to appear in court.
         But even if there’s a limited [requirement] to appear in court, it will pressure and deter investigators. Just think: if an investigator is always being called to testify in court over allegations of coercing confessions, he will become passive and embarrassed.
    2. There’s often no way to prove coerced confessions
    BN: Can these breakthroughs in the regulations be written into the Criminal Procedure Law?
    Xu: It should be possible to integrate them. We can say that these regulations are the fundamental rules regarding evidence in criminal cases, but that the current Criminal Procedure Law’s provisions regarding things like how to examine and judge evidence, how to accept evidence, how to establish the facts of a case, and precisely how to set the standard of proof are all very crude and difficult to carry out in practice.
    BN: How does this crudeness primarily manifest itself? Why do you say it’s difficult to carry out in practice?
    Xu: For example, in cases I’ve represented some defendants have alleged their confessions were obtained by coercion or disguised coercion—in other words, illegally obtained evidence [of the type] described in the new regulations—but they couldn’t prove it. This is where the difficulty lies.
    BN: Why couldn’t they prove it?
    Xu: First, if the lawyer is not present when a suspect is interrogated, there is no way to monitor and provide evidence. Defendants themselves are even less able to produce evidence. Even if there is bodily injury, how does one prove it is the result of an investigator’s beating? It is very possible to blame it on a cellmate or struggle during arrest.
         Moreover, the investigation period often lasts a long time, with several months to half a year before trial. Any wounds can heal [during that length of time].
    BN: Then what do you recommend to defendants about whether to speak out or not?
    Xu: I tell them to tell the truth. If something like that happened, you can and should speak up. But often there’s no way to confirm the allegation.
    BN: If the “victim” in the Zhao Zuohai case hadn’t returned alive, to this day there would probably be no way to prove [that Zhao’s confession had been coerced through torture].
    Xu: Why didn’t Zhao Zuohai petition [the court to rehear his case because his confession had been coerced]? Because petitioning was useless and the case couldn’t be overturned. Even the judge couldn’t confirm [the allegation], because he wasn’t present at the interrogation, either.
    3. The crux of the interrogation [problem] is lack of a third-party monitor
    BN: Based on your experience with criminal cases, why do you think that time and again it has been impossible to prohibit coercion of confessions?
    Xu: The reasons are many. The first is because of mindset and ideas. Even though the law provides for a presumption of innocence, some investigators still operate with a presumption of guilt, thinking, “I’ve caught you, so you must be guilty.” So, some investigators start off by asking suspects, “Do you know why we’ve arrested you?” or “If you say you’re innocent, show us proof.”
         Also, many law enforcement agents still focus on fighting crime and ignore the protection of human rights. They worry that they won’t be able to solve a case without a confession and will be too soft on a true criminal.
    BN: Isn’t fighting crime most important?
    Xu: According to the provisions of the Criminal Law and the Criminal Procedure Law, law enforcement agencies ought to fight crime as well as protect human rights, putting equal focus on each. Moreover, given a choice between being too soft and wrongly convicting someone, I’d rather be too soft on the occasional criminal than wrongly convict an innocent person. When a criminal is let off the hook, the violation is only one-way. But if you wrongly convict a good person, not only have you let the real criminal off the hook, you’ve also unjustly punished an innocent person, causing double the harm to society.
    BN: What are the systemic and institutional causes of [the failure to eliminate coerced confessions]?
    Xu: There are some specific systemic problems such as [emphasis on] the rates at which cases are solved, arrests are approved, and convictions are handed down, or [on] requiring that all capital cases be solved or that cases be solved within a particular period of time. Because of criteria for [performance] assessment, it seems as if the procuratorate must approve all arrests reported to it or all cases prosecuted at court must result in conviction—otherwise, it affects work [performance] results. This has a negative impact on the thorough implementation of the presumption of innocence and the exclusion of illegal evidence.
         As for the justice system, the law requires the public security, procuratorate, and courts to cooperate through division of labor and also to mutually check each other. But currently there’s more cooperation and the monitoring and checking functions aren’t really brought into play. For example, the public security organs all do their own investigation and interrogation. They take someone into custody and interrogate them, too. No approval is needed to place someone under criminal detention, and this detention can last up to more than 30 days. During detention, acts of illegally seeking evidence are common, such as repeated interrogation sessions lasting several dozen hours.
    BN: It seems as if all television crime series show suspects being subjected to overnight interrogation as soon as they are taken into custody. Even when striking a blow to the suspect’s face, the investigator’s face is serious, both dignified and devoted.
    Xu: Many countries don’t allow nighttime interrogations and prevent interrogations from exceeding a certain number of hours. We don’t have any regulations on this point. What’s more, many interrogations don’t take place in the detention center, but rather in the police station or some other location. At least there are many other people who can observe in the detention center, making coercion difficult. In the end, it’s a matter of not having the attorney present, not having a neutral third-party monitor.
    4. Time is ripe for granting suspects right to remain silent
    BN: Can enactment of these regulations stop the coercion of confessions?
    Xu: Stopping the coercion of confessions is a systemic project that requires comprehensive management. My personal view is that the best way is to grant defendants the right to remain silent and the right to have an attorney present.
    BN: Don’t the Law on Lawyers and the Criminal Procedure Law already provide for lawyers to intervene [in a case] during the investigative stage?
    Xu: The law allows a suspect to hire and meet with a lawyer from the moment of first interrogation or being placed under coercive measures. But in practice, lawyers are not present during the interrogation. If lawyers were present to monitor and witness, obtaining evidence illegally through coercion, fraud, or inducements would be impossible.
    BN: In other words, if the lawyer is not present, the suspect could refuse to answer?
    Xu: Right. This is the suspect’s right. Such provisions are primarily to ensure that confessions are made voluntarily. I’m even in favor of invalidating the record of a confession if the lawyer isn’t present.
    BN: Then the right to have a lawyer present should be provided for simultaneously with a suspect’s right to remain silent.
    Xu: Correct. The right to remain silent and the right to have a lawyer present (also known as the right to a lawyer’s assistance) are inseparable. The suspect’s right to remain silent is an international standard to prohibit forcing self-incrimination. A suspect has a right to an attorney’s assistance, and, if he has no money to hire a lawyer, the state should appoint an attorney to provide legal aid.
         If we could enact both of these rights simultaneously, it would be even better, but if they cannot be enacted simultaneously we should at least provide the right to have a lawyer present. A lawyer must be present especially when a confession of guilt is being made (except when the suspect voluntarily waives [the right]), in order to guarantee the voluntary and true nature of that confession of guilt.
    BN: Isn’t it a bit premature to have a right to remain silent as far as China is concerned? It’s still written [on the walls of] some detention centers: “Come clean and be treated leniently, resist and be treated severely.”
    Xu: Actually, it’s not premature. Many countries in the world have such provisions. It’s okay to require suspects to answer [questions] in a forthcoming way, but the problem is when the suspect truthfully answers with a defense that he is innocent and the officer handling the case believes that he is not answering truthfully.
    BN: Some investigators have complained that many cases won’t get solved if you enact a right to remain silent.
    Xu: In short, they still put too much emphasis on confessions. In fact, even some judges feel unsure [about how to handle a case] if there’s no confession or no one pleading guilty. Actually, the right to remain silent doesn’t encourage suspects to refuse to confess; rather, it emphasizes voluntary confessions in order to ensure their truthfulness and prevent unjust or error-filled cases. In countries [following] the Anglo-American [legal system], a trial is not even necessary if there’s a voluntary admission of guilt—they can go straight to sentencing. This shows they, too, place an emphasis on confession, but only if the confession is made with the assistance of an attorney and is made voluntarily, rather than being obtained through coercion.
  • Chinese Lawyer Interviewed on New Measures to Prevent Torture: “Key to Stopping Torture Is Presence of Counsel, Right to Silence”

    Over the past ten days, the Chinese media have been reporting on the recent adoption of two new sets of rules by China’s five main law enforcement institutions—the Supreme People’s Court, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security, the Ministry of State Security, and the Ministry of Justice. The “Regulations on Several Questions Concerning the Investigation and Judgment of Evidence in Handling Capital Cases” and “Regulations on Several Questions Concerning the Exclusion of Illegal Evidence in Handling Criminal Cases” (referred to below as “the regulations”) set out new procedural standards aimed at preventing criminal cases from being decided on the basis of illegally obtained evidence, especially evidence obtained through physical torture.
    As one might imagine, the coverage has been overwhelmingly positive, with several respected legal scholars endorsing the adoption of the regulations as major progress in China’s legal reform. The announcement of the rules could not be more timely considering the scandalous discovery last month that a man named Zhao Zuohai had served 11 years of a death sentence commuted to life imprisonment for a murder he did not commit, all because of a confession that had been extracted through police torture. But true assessment of the impact the new rules will likely have on preventing future cases of injustice must await their publication—at the time of this writing, the actual texts had not yet been released—and, more importantly, consideration of how thoroughly and enthusiastically they will be enforced.
    While acknowledging the importance of the new regulations as a first step, some Chinese lawyers in particular have pointed out that the problem of torture and use of illegal evidence is a systemic problem in China’s criminal justice system and that the new regulations might not be strong enough medicine to cure the disease. In a lengthy interview (translation below) with the Beijing News published on June 5, well-known criminal defense lawyer Xu Lanting argues that giving suspects the right to remain silent and, even more importantly, the right to have a lawyer present during questioning, would have a much greater impact on curbing the problem of coerced confessions.
    [Translator’s note: Chinese texts rarely refer to “torture” (kuxing) in discussions of the domestic context. China’s Criminal Law prohibits the use of corporal punishment or “disguised” corporal punishment to obtain a confession from a suspect or a witness statement, and this is the primary basis upon which China claims to prohibit torture. To reflect this practice, the text below routinely translates xingxun bigong literally as “coercion of confession,” rather than extrapolating with the word “torture.”]
    *
    1. Having interrogators appear in court is of great significance
    Beijing News (BN): Media reports on the regulations have universally focused on the sections concerning coerced confessions. How do you rate this content?
    Xu Lanting: Each country primarily uses “rules on the exclusion of evidence” to stop coerced confessions, for example by ruling that evidence obtained through coerced confessions is illegal and cannot be used. This forces the investigating organ to stop relying on coerced confessions to obtain evidence.
         The enactment and thorough enforcement of these new regulations are of major significance in [the effort to] stop the coercion of confessions and other illegal methods of obtaining evidence, as well as in the protection of human rights.
         First of all, they overcome past limitations that excluded only illegal statements and clarify that illegally obtained physical evidence and documentary evidence will also be excluded. “When physical evidence or documentary evidence is clearly obtained in violation of the law and could possibly have an impact on the fairness of the adjudication, [the court] should order redress or make a reasonable explanation; otherwise, the physical evidence or documentary evidence in question may not be used to determine a case.”
    BN: I understand that in some countries any evidence obtained through coerced statements is categorically excluded. Are there loopholes in our regulations?
    Xu: In the United States, this kind of evidence is called “fruit of the poisonous tree” and is categorically excluded. There’s debate about this among Chinese academics. Some advocate that consideration be made of specific circumstances on a case-by-case basis, [and so] if the violations of law involved in obtaining some physical evidence is not too serious or it can be used after making redress, it shouldn’t be excluded.
         My own view is that any physical evidence obtained in ways that violate the law—especially through leads provided in coerced confessions—should also be excluded. Otherwise, there will be no way to eliminate coerced confessions. [The investigator] will think, “I’ll beat you first to get a confession. I might not be able to use that confession, but I can then rely on that confession to find other evidence.”
    BN: What breakthroughs do the regulations have in the area of procedures for excluding illegal evidence?
    Xu: The regulations establish five procedural stages: initiation of the proceedings, preliminary court investigation, the prosecution’s presentation of proof, examination of the evidence by both sides, and the court’s decision. In the past, provisions in this area only took the form of principles or slogans. Now there is a big improvement because there is a clear procedure that is more practicable.
         It’s worth pointing out that, unlike in the past, investigators will give testimony in court. Also, if the prosecution’s evidence is not credible or sufficient enough to rule out that a defendant’s pre-trial statements were obtained illegally, the court may rule those statements to be illegal and exclude them. On a certain level, this can be seen as “inverting the burden of proof” and forcing the investigating organ to preserve the interrogation [process] through audio and video recording.
    BN: But this so-called [requirement that] investigators give testimony in court is still passive, being initiated only after defendants or their defense attorneys make allegations of coerced confessions. Why can’t China do like some other countries and make court appearances by investigators routine?
    Xu: It’s true that in some countries it’s routine for investigators to testify in court. In countries that follow the Anglo-American system of law, investigators are treated as witnesses and all witnesses must appear in court or else their testimony is treated as hearsay and cannot be used. I’ve also observed that some European countries’ trial systems make their investigators appear in court, even if only to state how they originally took the suspect into custody.
         Our regulations can only be considered a “limited principle on court appearance,” but this is realistic and reasonable. First, it’s probably impossible at present to make investigators in each case appear in court, and it’s not necessary. If there’s no argument over the records and statements, then there’s no need [for investigators] to appear in court.
         But even if there’s a limited [requirement] to appear in court, it will pressure and deter investigators. Just think: if an investigator is always being called to testify in court over allegations of coercing confessions, he will become passive and embarrassed.
    2. There’s often no way to prove coerced confessions
    BN: Can these breakthroughs in the regulations be written into the Criminal Procedure Law?
    Xu: It should be possible to integrate them. We can say that these regulations are the fundamental rules regarding evidence in criminal cases, but that the current Criminal Procedure Law’s provisions regarding things like how to examine and judge evidence, how to accept evidence, how to establish the facts of a case, and precisely how to set the standard of proof are all very crude and difficult to carry out in practice.
    BN: How does this crudeness primarily manifest itself? Why do you say it’s difficult to carry out in practice?
    Xu: For example, in cases I’ve represented some defendants have alleged their confessions were obtained by coercion or disguised coercion—in other words, illegally obtained evidence [of the type] described in the new regulations—but they couldn’t prove it. This is where the difficulty lies.
    BN: Why couldn’t they prove it?
    Xu: First, if the lawyer is not present when a suspect is interrogated, there is no way to monitor and provide evidence. Defendants themselves are even less able to produce evidence. Even if there is bodily injury, how does one prove it is the result of an investigator’s beating? It is very possible to blame it on a cellmate or struggle during arrest.
         Moreover, the investigation period often lasts a long time, with several months to half a year before trial. Any wounds can heal [during that length of time].
    BN: Then what do you recommend to defendants about whether to speak out or not?
    Xu: I tell them to tell the truth. If something like that happened, you can and should speak up. But often there’s no way to confirm the allegation.
    BN: If the “victim” in the Zhao Zuohai case hadn’t returned alive, to this day there would probably be no way to prove [that Zhao’s confession had been coerced through torture].
    Xu: Why didn’t Zhao Zuohai petition [the court to rehear his case because his confession had been coerced]? Because petitioning was useless and the case couldn’t be overturned. Even the judge couldn’t confirm [the allegation], because he wasn’t present at the interrogation, either.
    3. The crux of the interrogation [problem] is lack of a third-party monitor
    BN: Based on your experience with criminal cases, why do you think that time and again it has been impossible to prohibit coercion of confessions?
    Xu: The reasons are many. The first is because of mindset and ideas. Even though the law provides for a presumption of innocence, some investigators still operate with a presumption of guilt, thinking, “I’ve caught you, so you must be guilty.” So, some investigators start off by asking suspects, “Do you know why we’ve arrested you?” or “If you say you’re innocent, show us proof.”
         Also, many law enforcement agents still focus on fighting crime and ignore the protection of human rights. They worry that they won’t be able to solve a case without a confession and will be too soft on a true criminal.
    BN: Isn’t fighting crime most important?
    Xu: According to the provisions of the Criminal Law and the Criminal Procedure Law, law enforcement agencies ought to fight crime as well as protect human rights, putting equal focus on each. Moreover, given a choice between being too soft and wrongly convicting someone, I’d rather be too soft on the occasional criminal than wrongly convict an innocent person. When a criminal is let off the hook, the violation is only one-way. But if you wrongly convict a good person, not only have you let the real criminal off the hook, you’ve also unjustly punished an innocent person, causing double the harm to society.
    BN: What are the systemic and institutional causes of [the failure to eliminate coerced confessions]?
    Xu: There are some specific systemic problems such as [emphasis on] the rates at which cases are solved, arrests are approved, and convictions are handed down, or [on] requiring that all capital cases be solved or that cases be solved within a particular period of time. Because of criteria for [performance] assessment, it seems as if the procuratorate must approve all arrests reported to it or all cases prosecuted at court must result in conviction—otherwise, it affects work [performance] results. This has a negative impact on the thorough implementation of the presumption of innocence and the exclusion of illegal evidence.
         As for the justice system, the law requires the public security, procuratorate, and courts to cooperate through division of labor and also to mutually check each other. But currently there’s more cooperation and the monitoring and checking functions aren’t really brought into play. For example, the public security organs all do their own investigation and interrogation. They take someone into custody and interrogate them, too. No approval is needed to place someone under criminal detention, and this detention can last up to more than 30 days. During detention, acts of illegally seeking evidence are common, such as repeated interrogation sessions lasting several dozen hours.
    BN: It seems as if all television crime series show suspects being subjected to overnight interrogation as soon as they are taken into custody. Even when striking a blow to the suspect’s face, the investigator’s face is serious, both dignified and devoted.
    Xu: Many countries don’t allow nighttime interrogations and prevent interrogations from exceeding a certain number of hours. We don’t have any regulations on this point. What’s more, many interrogations don’t take place in the detention center, but rather in the police station or some other location. At least there are many other people who can observe in the detention center, making coercion difficult. In the end, it’s a matter of not having the attorney present, not having a neutral third-party monitor.
    4. Time is ripe for granting suspects right to remain silent
    BN: Can enactment of these regulations stop the coercion of confessions?
    Xu: Stopping the coercion of confessions is a systemic project that requires comprehensive management. My personal view is that the best way is to grant defendants the right to remain silent and the right to have an attorney present.
    BN: Don’t the Law on Lawyers and the Criminal Procedure Law already provide for lawyers to intervene [in a case] during the investigative stage?
    Xu: The law allows a suspect to hire and meet with a lawyer from the moment of first interrogation or being placed under coercive measures. But in practice, lawyers are not present during the interrogation. If lawyers were present to monitor and witness, obtaining evidence illegally through coercion, fraud, or inducements would be impossible.
    BN: In other words, if the lawyer is not present, the suspect could refuse to answer?
    Xu: Right. This is the suspect’s right. Such provisions are primarily to ensure that confessions are made voluntarily. I’m even in favor of invalidating the record of a confession if the lawyer isn’t present.
    BN: Then the right to have a lawyer present should be provided for simultaneously with a suspect’s right to remain silent.
    Xu: Correct. The right to remain silent and the right to have a lawyer present (also known as the right to a lawyer’s assistance) are inseparable. The suspect’s right to remain silent is an international standard to prohibit forcing self-incrimination. A suspect has a right to an attorney’s assistance, and, if he has no money to hire a lawyer, the state should appoint an attorney to provide legal aid.
         If we could enact both of these rights simultaneously, it would be even better, but if they cannot be enacted simultaneously we should at least provide the right to have a lawyer present. A lawyer must be present especially when a confession of guilt is being made (except when the suspect voluntarily waives [the right]), in order to guarantee the voluntary and true nature of that confession of guilt.
    BN: Isn’t it a bit premature to have a right to remain silent as far as China is concerned? It’s still written [on the walls of] some detention centers: “Come clean and be treated leniently, resist and be treated severely.”
    Xu: Actually, it’s not premature. Many countries in the world have such provisions. It’s okay to require suspects to answer [questions] in a forthcoming way, but the problem is when the suspect truthfully answers with a defense that he is innocent and the officer handling the case believes that he is not answering truthfully.
    BN: Some investigators have complained that many cases won’t get solved if you enact a right to remain silent.
    Xu: In short, they still put too much emphasis on confessions. In fact, even some judges feel unsure [about how to handle a case] if there’s no confession or no one pleading guilty. Actually, the right to remain silent doesn’t encourage suspects to refuse to confess; rather, it emphasizes voluntary confessions in order to ensure their truthfulness and prevent unjust or error-filled cases. In countries [following] the Anglo-American [legal system], a trial is not even necessary if there’s a voluntary admission of guilt—they can go straight to sentencing. This shows they, too, place an emphasis on confession, but only if the confession is made with the assistance of an attorney and is made voluntarily, rather than being obtained through coercion.
  • Zhao Zuohai Case Provokes Responses on Legal Protections from Chinese Public, Government

    Zhao Zuohai spent more than a decade in prison after a court convicted him of murdering a man in a hatchet fight. A headless corpse had been found in a well in central Henan Province, and police surmised that it belonged to a man who had gone missing after fighting with Zhao. Zhao was sentenced to death, suspended for two years, in large part on the basis of a confession he provided to investigators. Zhao claimed that he made the confession after investigators subjected him to beatings and forced him to stay awake for a month, but those claims had never been given much credence until early last month, when the man Zhao was supposed to have murdered suddenly reappeared.
    The response to Zhao’s case has been swift. Within a week, he was acquitted of all charges and released from prison. Days later, he was awarded 650,000 yuan (US$96,000) in state compensation, an amount that may have been in line with Chinese law but that nevertheless has to be considered small in light of the loss and suffering he had undergone. The case elicited considerable public commentary, much of it critical of a law enforcement system in which defendants’ rights receive few protections. In apparent response to this criticism, China’s law enforcement authorities recently issued new rules aimed at strengthening evidentiary requirements in death penalty cases and clarifying procedures for excluding evidence, including statements and confessions, that have been extracted through torture.
    Among the commentaries published in response to Zhao Zuohai’s case was an exchange that appeared in the Southern Metropolis Daily on May 17 and 18. Though Wu Zhifeng takes issue with some of the points made in Shen Bin’s earlier article, the distance between the two authors actually does not seem that great on the key importance of rule of law. Shen articulates a wariness many legal experts in China feel about public opinion’s influence over the exercise of law enforcement—especially when it appears that authorities bend the rules or even break the law in an effort to respond to public sentiment. Wu questions the extent to which law enforcement efforts are influenced by public opinion in China, arguing instead that corners are cut and abuses perpetrated in efforts to satisfy instructions and performance expectations imposed from above—what he calls law enforcement’s willingness to cater to “official opinion.” Both authors agree on the importance of a certain level of autonomy for the Chinese criminal justice system as a guarantee of its fair administration of justice.
    *
    “Basis of Popular Opinion” Contributing to the Zhao Zuohai Case of Injustice
    Shen Bin
         Without a doubt, the injustice done to Zhao Zuohai has been a focus of recent public opinion. This case of injustice that lasted 11 years has given the public an opportunity to reflect on China’s legal system and the interactive relationship between public opinion and the judicial system.
         Earlier, I wrote a piece entitled “Is the Detention of the Police in the ‘Zhao Zuohai Case’ the Beginning of Yet More Illegality?” (published in the May 14 Oriental Morning News). In it, I wrote that detaining the police who tortured Zhao Zuohai 11 years ago may have brought much public applause, but it may involve a serious legal mistake and even perhaps be the beginning of yet more illegality. This is because Article 87 of the Criminal Law states that when the maximum punishment prescribed is fixed-term imprisonment of less than five years, a crime cannot be prosecuted after five years has passed. However, Article 247 of the Criminal Law provides a maximum three-year sentence for forcibly extracting confessions, so the statute of limitations on the crime of torture is five years. Therefore, in principle, Zhao Zuohai’s case has already exceeded the period in which the case can be prosecuted, so law-enforcement bodies cannot prosecute this criminal act unless there are exceptional circumstances as provided by law, such as Zhao lodging an accusation at the time but no case being filed [for investigation], or the three police officers committing other criminal acts within the statute of limitations. [My article] resulted in a flood of criticism from netizens. Why would a decision that appears to be clearly illegal be supported by a majority of people? Is popular opinion wrong? Where’s the problem?
         What’s more, I’ve come to realize that the Zhao Zuohai case exists thanks to a process of transformation that occurs when public authority panders to “popular opinion.”
         Eleven years ago, when an anonymous corpse was discovered in a well, the local public security system internally set a rule that “murder cases must be solved” in order to “ensure the safety of the masses.” As a result, Zhao Zuohai was subjected to brutal police torture and confessed to false charges.
         In 2002, a mammoth nationwide effort to clear cases of extended detention was launched, and the results in Henan Province that year were brilliant: “By the end of 2002, Henan had cleared more than 5,000 individual cases of extended detention; with only slightly more than 20 individual cases of extended detention [still on record], basically there were no more cases of extended detention remaining.” Zhao Zuohai was one of these 5,000 cases of “cleared extended detention.” For two years beyond the legal detention period, Zhao had been caught in limbo between release and trial because the facts of his case weren’t clear and the evidence was insufficient. In response to this “great clearing up,” the local political and legal committee ignored the legal principle of “when in doubt, tend towards acquittal” and decided to force through criminal charges against Zhao.
         Of course, the public is not wrong for demanding that the police solve criminal cases or that cases of extended detention be cleared up. The problem arises when public opinion becomes “great popular anger” in the extreme, and higher levels turn this into a form of performance evaluation that exerts pressure all the way down to the lowest levels, so that those lowest levels, out of a sense of responsibility to higher levels of authority, use whatever means necessary to accomplish the tasks handed them.
         So when the public demands “murder cases must be solved,” the result is torture. When the public demands clearing of cases of extended detention, the result is that Zhao Zuohai is prosecuted. When the public demands redress of a case of injustice, public authority may break the statute of limitations and detain the police for torture once upon a time . . . . Popular opinion is always correct and reasonable, but in the hands of authority, it is transformed and twisted so that popular opinion ultimately turns against itself.
         There’s no quick fix for the most fundamental reasons underlying all of this. Today’s responsible media and citizens, in their interactions with government, should have a rational understanding of how the legal system operates and the capacity and responsibility of the government. They should weigh the pros and cons of government’s administrative and legal policies, and guide popular opinion and government actions toward a positive interaction, avoiding the kind of vicious cycle that has appeared in the Zhao Zuohai case.
         Taking the solution rate for criminal cases as an example, the media and the government should not focus on “murder cases must be solved” without limitations and take pride in China’s high solution rate, because it comes with a price that [ultimately] must be explained to the public. For example, according to official reports, the solution rate for murder cases in China in 2005 was 87.2 percent, reaching the levels in Japan and Germany and outpacing England (87 percent) and the United States (63 percent). Behind this pretty number are the facts: case after case of forcibly extracted confession, round-the-clock interrogation, and interrogation-until-exhaustion by individual police at the local level, as well as police in certain areas who, chasing a high solution rate, don’t file cases for investigation until they’ve solved them. As the point of departure for public opinion to provide rational feedback to government actions, information should be diverse and multi-dimensional. The kind of “black-and-white” view of justice seen in traditional theater runs counter to the modern spirit of rule of law. Therefore, rational public opinion shouldn’t demand that the government “solve all cases” but should understand that, sometimes, police “inabilities” are [actually] strengths. In fact, if police were truly to “solve all cases,” citizens’ legal rights would be harmed.
         Modern rule of law is multi-dimensional and has pros and cons. It is not all-powerful and can only safeguard justice through achievement of supreme procedural justice. However, this doesn’t mean that all cases of injustice can be eliminated. Some bad guys will go free. There is often a gap between the rule of law and popular opinion. Can we accept this “spirit of the law”? Rule of law is a sign of a mature, reasonable nation. I hope that the reflection surrounding the Zhao Zuohai case won’t stop at the level of “a life for a life.”

    The author is a legal worker in Shanghai.
    *
    Is there a “Basis of Official Opinion” in the Zhao Zuohai Case of Injustice?: A Response to the May 17 Opinion
    Wu Zhifeng
         Besides maintaining that the detention of police responsible for committing torture more than a decade ago appears to be an illegal act designed to cater to public opinion, Shen Bin also believes that the Zhao Zuohai case exists thanks to a process of transformation that occurs when public authority panders to “popular opinion” and that it was popular demand that “murder cases must be solved” that led police to seek quick success and employ brutal torture to get a confession. On these points, I beg to disagree.
         Zhao Zuohai repeatedly made claims of torture to the court and the procuratorate in the course of the proceedings against him, but neither paid sufficient heed to those claims at the time or filed a case [for investigation.] This should be considered a circumstance in which the statute of limitations is not applicable. Moreover, having objectively taken into account that petitioning [the court for consideration of retrial] results in the docking of points and inability to get a sentence reduction, Zhao Zuohai’s thinking and actions were unquestionably twisted by the legal system as he understood it, to the extent that he was deprived of his “right” to file a complaint. Having recovered his liberty, he is now justified in seeking to recover this lost right. And what’s the problem if public opinion expresses sympathy for the harm done to Zhao Zuohai and calls for the realization of his legitimate rights and for belated justice to redress the serious damage done to his body and mind? If pressure from popular opinion can bring about reflection and remedy from the present legal system so that the gaps that cause these kinds of unjust cases can be filled and if it can bring about progress in the legal system and further steps towards fairness and justice, this would be a positive interaction between public opinion and the legal system.
         But the origins of the Zhao Zuohai case cannot be glossed by public authority’s pandering to popular opinion. Popular opinion demands that public authority be used to punish the truly dangerous, not to put forward a scapegoat or, even worse, use illegal means to cause innocent people to be executed. The pressure of public opinion is ultimately flexible, [comprising] demands based on a case’s facts and legal principles; it does not replace the power of law enforcement when handling a particular case. Faced with a flood of public opinion, law enforcement should stick to the fundamental principle of remaining in harmony with it. But in the course of handling a specific case, [law enforcement] has its own rational judgment and procedures to follow and cannot change them because of popular opinion at a particular place and time. A crime wave or the reappearance of criminal behavior is a matter for the police. Establishing guilt and passing sentence is a matter for the courts. Using the facts as the basis and the law as a guide, the judicial system must obey the facts and the law. This is the premise and foundation of what constitutes the legal system, its beginning and its end. It is rubbish to blame public opinion for the illegal handling of a case.
         What’s more, how much heed did those guys who illegally handled the case pay to public opinion, anyway? What kind of public opinion can corrupt the enforcement of the law? My guess is that, in the end, what they were concerned about was “official opinion,” the pressure that assessments by higher-ups would have on their official record, their career, and their personal interests. I’m afraid it misses the mark to talk about public opinion whenever law enforcement submits to official opinion and fails to maintain the principle of independence in handling cases. Dressing up official opinion as public opinion and using it as a defense for cases that were illegally handled could become the best straw torturers have to clutch in a courtroom. From this perspective, when we search for the origins of a case of injustice we shouldn’t falsely accuse “public opinion” and let the true culprit of “official opinion” off the hook, lest we create the “unjust case of public opinion.” Exposing the “basis of official opinion” in the Zhao Zuohai case is much more worthwhile than exposing the “basis of public opinion.” By doing so, we allow formal justice and substantive justice to be better reflected in the legal system and do more to aid the early formation of a society with rule of law.
  • Editorial Calls for Assertion of Civil Rights in Face of Chinese Police Torture

    China’s police are again facing criticism after the latest in a string of embarrassing detainee deaths. Three top police officers in Lushan County, Henan, lost their jobs and four more officers face criminal prosecution following the death of Wang Yahui, a suspected thief who died suddenly in the county detention center on February 21, three days after being taken into custody.A police official initially told a local television station that Wang had died after drinking some hot water during his interrogation, a claim immediately subjected to derision online. Wang’s family members demanded an autopsy after finding injuries to his chest, arms, head, and genitals, injuries that ultimately forcing police to accept responsibility for his death.

    In April 2009, China’s State Council Information Office and Ministry of Foreign Affairs jointly released the “National Human Rights Action Plan (2009–2010),” which it promoted as a document guiding all government departments’ human rights work during the two-year period. In a section on guaranteeing the rights of the person, the plan makes clear that torture and illegal detention are prohibited under Chinese law and that violators are subject to criminal prosecution. Unlike elsewhere in the plan, no new concrete measures were introduced to address abuses in the criminal justice system, giving the impression that existing legislation and enforcement efforts are adequate to do the job.

    Yet, during the first quarter of 2009 alone, there were a number of widely discussed unnatural deaths of individuals held in Chinese detention facilities. The death of 24-year-old Li Qiaoming in Jinning, Yunnan, was initially attributed to a deadly game of jailhouse “hide-and-seek,” but a later investigation eventually led officials to acknowledge that Li had been beaten to death by other inmates. In Shaanxi, 19-year-old Xu Gengrong died under mysterious circumstances after seven days of detention, and officials in Jiujiang, Jiangxi, blamed the death of 50-year-old Li Wenyan on a “nightmare.”

    Anecdotal evidence suggests these incidents are not aberrations in an otherwise stellar record of fighting torture, as the Chinese government has attempted to argue over the years. Instead, they appear to exemplify commonplace abuse that has been identified for years without substantive efforts being taken to address them. The response to these incidents by the Ministry of Public Security, which runs China’s system of detention centers, was to announce a three-month campaign to “boost professional ethics, law awareness, and respect for human rights” at prisons and detention centers. However, this effort to rectify serious deficiencies through an “in-house” campaign of education shows a remarkable lack of innovation and an excessive reliance on measures that have been tried before without yielding tangible results.

    “Brave” efforts are necessary to eliminate torture, says an editorial (translated by Dui Hua below) published Tuesday in Southern Metropolis Daily, a Guangzhou-based newspaper known for its relatively outspoken and liberal positions. In the newspaper’s view, blame lies within the entire culture of interactions between legal authorities and ordinary citizens. Both police and the public have been conditioned to believe that citizens should be docile when confronted by police power, a situation that can naturally lead to a debasement of civil rights. The editorial warns that criminal sanctions against the few law enforcement agents who get caught torturing detainees will not ultimately change this mentality. What is needed instead is for citizens themselves to assert their own civil rights and, in doing so, demand that law enforcement institutions respect those rights as a matter of principle.

    This call for citizen “bravery” in defense of civil rights is itself an act of great daring, as its use of the potentially controversial phrase “rights protection” (weiquan) leaves open the possibility for Chinese citizens to assert their rights in the face of public authority in other contexts. More “demand from below” may in fact be what is needed in order to realize the many rights and protections promised by China’s constitution, but it remains to be seen whether more will be done “from the top” to make such assertions of civil rights less risky.

    *Eliminating Torture Awaits Citizens’ Bravery in Protecting Rights
    Editorial, Southern Metropolis Daily, March 2, 2010

        Torture by police in Lushan County, Henan, led to the death of suspect Wang Yahui. This recent admission by the provincial public security department shattered the earlier ridiculous cover-up. The chief of the Lushan County Public Security Bureau has been ordered to resign, and the responsible deputy bureau chief and the head of the criminal investigations unit were sacked, both facing additional disciplinary measures pending investigation of responsibility. The Pingdingshan Public Security Bureau’s deputy chief in charge of criminal investigations and the officer responsible for detention center management are also facing disciplinary measures. Four police officers involved were sent to the procuratorate on suspicion of torture. Earlier, when the deceased’s family members publicly reported to the media that they discovered serious injuries all over his body, the local public security bureau claimed that Wang had “died after drinking hot water” during interrogation.

        Wang Yahui is not the first victim to have had his life taken away by torture, and he probably will not be the last. However, it seems as if cases like this, in which police arbitrarily snuff out human lives in confined spaces and then give increasingly ridiculous explanations, have been occurring with some frequency. There is a barbarism and darkness about these cases, reflected both in the boundlessness of the methods used to extract confessions and the utter stupidity of the mendacity.
        Analysts mostly view the origins of torture from the perspective of law enforcement agencies, seeing its cause in the obsession for confessions or pointing to the lack of effective supervision over judicial powers, including the police, that makes it impossible to check these kinds of “work-related crimes.” These views are not mistaken, as even the silent corpses of these Wang Yahuis can confirm. The mechanisms leading to torture are so simple as to be scary, but the problem is not simply with the agents or institutions of law enforcement; the problem is also that citizens, when faced with police and other legal authority, usually find themselves in a position of [having] inferior rights.
        Everyone knows that even criminal suspects enjoy fundamental human rights and are entitled to lawful treatment. But terrible acts of torture make clear that some police use seemingly lawful methods to carry out great acts of illegal violations. Citizens’ inferior rights appear again and again in their interactions with police. In some ways, though these Wang Yahuis appear to have died because of violent extraction of confessions, in fact they died because of extreme cases of inferior rights in which the protective barrier of rights had been thoroughly destroyed.
        The law categorizes torture as a work-related crime. In rendering a verdict, it is of course necessary to make clear distinctions [between crimes], but in terms of torture cases, in which the right to life is crudely stripped away, it is not because law enforcement agents do not appropriately use the “authority associated with their work duties” but that “work duties” are just an excuse. Actually, in a situation of inferior rights, law enforcement officers engaging in torture do not merely exceed the authority of their positions; they also unleash human evil capable of killing others. This kind of evil is not necessarily something the criminal law can stop, as it is capable of evolving into a dark force that can devour humans.
        It is not only [a problem] in detention centers and interrogation rooms. Actually, in other situations where citizens and police interact, the expected relationship between the two is often out of balance. One-sided emphasis on submission of rights to authority, where police can use coercive powers at will, implies that they can overwhelm civil rights. When these kinds of police powers are repeatedly used in the course of dealings with citizens, it naturally strengthens the idea that police must tame the public. This demonstrates that the situation of inferior rights that exists in torture is not random. There is, in fact, a source for this distortion.
        Upgrading internal supervision of the law enforcement organs is a necessary, but not sufficient, part of eliminating torture. Even more important is implementing the rights of lawyers to fully participate [in the legal process] and carry out defense without obstruction as well as civil rights, such as prohibition [of prosecution] based solely on confession and the right to remain silent. Before and after the deaths of these Wang Yahuis, the legal system has been cleansed repeatedly, but citizens’ assertions of their rights still face restrictions. In this day and age of extensive contacts between police and citizens, we should reverse this situation of inferior civil rights as soon as possible and, thereby, end the illegal use of violence by police.
        Wang Yahui’s death by torture has led to public denunciations of rogue police, condemnations that contain both righteous anger over another’s tragedy and, implicitly, worries about the unsettled condition of one’s own rights. Fear is of no use; the rational thing to do is for each person to recognize the scope of his or her rights and, in dealings with the legal system (including the police), remain firm in protecting those rights and bravely create a situation in which the coercive institutions revere the rights of citizens. This is a viable path, and the inferior state of [civil] rights is alerting us to make more attempts.
  • Chinese Officials on Presence of Counsel and Torture Cases Against Investigators

    A recent article from a Chinese government web site discusses the failure of China’s legal mechanisms to guarantee the presence of counsel during criminal interrogation, which can leave suspects vulnerable to illegal coercion at the hands of investigators. It also touches on the burden on criminal investigators to disprove torture charges against them stemming from cases of forced confessions. With comments attributed to officials from China’s main criminal justice bodies, the article (PDF with Dui Hua’s translation) prescribes several measures to help China improve protection of the human rights of criminal suspects.
     
    The piece echoes the position the Chinese government has held for years: investigators still use force, including elements of torture, to coerce confessions, and China has expressed a commitment to curb this problem through legal and penal reform. The use of torture to force confessions has been a criminal offense in China since 1979, and torture during interrogation explicitly violates the United Nations Convention Against Torture, which China ratified in 1988.
     
    In China, a confession by a criminal suspect who is later brought to trial all but ensures a guilty verdict (and possible prison sentence) since virtually all such suspects in criminal cases are convicted. And in the Chinese penal system, forced confessions from prisoners who initially attempted to maintain their innocence have been linked to reduced sentences or better treatment, a practice that has received intense international criticism.
     
    Positive changes in these and other areas are expected to accompany reform of China’s criminal procedure law, drafts of which have been circulating and may soon receive a reading by the National People’s Congress. If provisions to improve access to legal counsel and “presumption of innocence” are eventually included and effectively implemented, it would help safeguard suspects from being coerced into confessing guilt and bolster progress toward better human rights protections and established rule of law in China.
     

    Dui Hua has paid close attention to the issues of torture and forced confessions, most prominently in its Dialogue cover story (PDF) and interview with the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture (PDF) in 2006 on the use of torture in China.


    Related link: